Concert Reviews
A chronological ledger of live sets. Gut ratings, pairwise power rankings, venues, notes, and the occasional uncomfortable amount of analysis.
Overview
Starting in late 2023 I began keeping a simple 1–10 log of shows. Each set has two numbers: is the gut rating, written down the night of, and is the power rank, fitted from head-to-head comparisons between sets. Older shows receive a slight correction for recency bias. Sets I haven't compared yet are greyed out — their power rank is just the gut rating restated.
7.46.9 ledger average1,019 comparisonstypically ±1.0
Top five sets
- events
- 56
- sets
- 221
- artists
- 174
- in 2026
- 13
Leaderboard
Leaderboard
Top Rated
Most Seen
Rankings
Power ranks, fitted (Bradley-Terry) from every head-to-head judgement.
Top 10
- 01Fred Again Cow Palace · Dec 5, 202510.0 ±0.714–0
- 02Rufus Du Sol Shoreline · Aug 14, 202510.0 ±0.412–2
- 03Anti Up Pier 80 Warehouse · Sep 20, 202510.0 ±0.57–3–1
- 04Fred Again Bill Graham · Jun 1, 20249.8 ±0.313–5
- 05WhoMadeWho Coachella · Apr 19, 20269.7 ±0.419–3–1
- 06Adriatique Coachella · Apr 18, 20269.7 ±0.76–0–1↑1
- 07Dom Dolla Coachella · Apr 13, 20249.6 ±0.46–5↓1
- 08Fisher Golden Gate Park · Aug 12, 20239.6 ±0.310–8–2
- 09Fisher Pier 80 · Sep 29, 20249.5 ±0.310–6–2
- 10Underworld Pier 80 · Sep 21, 20259.4 ±0.45–6
Show all 221 compared sets →Show fewer ←
- 11Sammy Virji Golden Gate Park · Aug 10, 20259.3 ±0.46–6–1
- 12Barry Can't Swim Pier 80 · Sep 29, 20249.2 ±0.57–3↑11
- 13Rufus Du Sol Pier 80 · Sep 28, 20249.2 ±0.413–4↓1
- 14Charlotte de Witte Coachella · Apr 13, 20249.1 ±0.56–3–1↓1
- 15Jungle Coachella · Apr 13, 20249.1 ±0.55–4↓1
- 16Overmono Pier 80 Warehouse · Sep 27, 20269.0 ±0.66–1↓1
- 17Everything Always Coachella · Apr 12, 20249.0 ±0.56–3↑3
- 18Dom Dolla Pier 80 · Sep 21, 20258.9 ±0.45–7↓2
- 19Hamdi Cow Palace · Dec 5, 20258.9 ±0.222–14↓2
- 20Nine Inch Noize Coachella · Apr 18, 20268.9 ±0.57–2↓2
- 21Peggy Gou Pier 80 Warehouse · Sep 21, 20258.9 ±0.54–4↓2
- 22Justice Bill Graham · May 22, 20258.8 ±0.47–5
- 23Justice Bill Graham · May 21, 20258.7 ±0.46–4↓2
- 24Dua Lipa Chase Center · Oct 12, 20258.6 ±0.45–6↑3
- 25Four Tet Pier 80 Warehouse · Sep 28, 20248.6 ±0.45–4↑1
- 26Disclosure Pier 80 · Sep 29, 20248.6 ±0.54–4↑2
- 27John Summit Coachella · Apr 14, 20248.6 ±0.45–5↓2
- 28Gorgon City Coachella · Apr 12, 20248.5 ±0.56–3↓4
- 29Oppidan Cow Palace · Dec 5, 20258.5 ±0.47–4↑2
- 30Rufus Du Sol Golden Gate Park · Aug 9, 20268.5 ±0.63–2–1↑2
- 31Justice Pier 80 · Sep 29, 20248.4 ±0.55–4↓1
- 32Four Tet Pier 80 Warehouse · Dec 30, 20258.4 ±0.55–3↑1
- 33Four Tet Pier 80 Warehouse · Sep 27, 20268.4 ±0.55–2↑3
- 34Underworld Pier 48 · May 16, 20268.3 ±0.54–3↑1
- 35Franky Rizardo Coachella · Apr 17, 20268.3 ±0.65–2↑13
- 36Alesso Midway · Jul 6, 20248.3 ±0.55–3↑1
- 37Solomun Pier 48 · May 15, 20268.3 ±0.55–2↑9
- 38Barry Can't Swim Coachella · Apr 14, 20248.3 ±0.54–4↓9
- 39Chris Lake Bill Graham · Nov 15, 20258.3 ±0.54–4↓5
- 40The xx Coachella · Apr 17, 20268.3 ±0.56–3↑5
- 41John Summit Pier 80 Warehouse · Jan 1, 20268.3 ±0.46–4↓2
- 42L'Impératrice Golden Gate Park · Aug 12, 20238.2 ±0.55–3↓2
- 43Daphni Pier 80 · Sep 27, 20268.2 ±0.54–2↓2
- 44Chris Lake Golden Gate Park · Aug 10, 20248.2 ±0.45–5↓2
- 45Alesso Coachella · Apr 14, 20248.1 ±0.53–4↓2
- 46DJ Pee Wee Golden Gate Park · Aug 9, 20258.1 ±0.54–3↓2
- 47Skrillex Bill Graham · Jun 1, 20248.1 ±0.53–6
- 48Glass Beams Pier 80 · Sep 29, 20248.1 ±0.54–3↑2
- 49Mau P Pier 48 · Mar 13, 20268.1 ±0.63–3
- 50Tove Lo Pier 80 · Sep 26, 20268.0 ±0.54–3↓12
- 51Jamie xx Golden Gate Park · Aug 10, 20258.0 ±0.55–4
- 52Odesza Golden Gate Park · Aug 13, 20238.0 ±0.56–3
- 53Lorde Greek Theater · Oct 19, 20257.9 ±0.54–4↑1
- 54Jamie xx Madison Square Garden · Oct 30, 20267.8 ±0.54–2↑55
- 55Disclosure Coachella · Apr 17, 20267.8 ±0.46–4↓2
- 56Jungle Greek Theater · Oct 6, 20267.8 ±0.55–2↑2
- 57Adriatique + Cloonee Coachella · Apr 19, 20267.8 ±0.66–1↓1
- 58Purple Disco Machine Pier 80 Warehouse · Jan 1, 20267.8 ±0.55–3↑2
- 59Disclosure Pier 80 Warehouse · Dec 29, 20257.8 ±0.52–5↓2
- 60Chris Stussy Pier 80 Warehouse · Sep 21, 20257.7 ±0.55–5↓5
- 61Blond:ish Independent · Aug 9, 20257.7 ±0.48–8↓2
- 62L'Impératrice Zilker Park · Oct 8, 20227.7 ±0.54–3
- 63Kaleena Zanders Golden Gate Park · Aug 10, 20247.6 ±0.56–2
- 64DRAMA Coachella · Apr 19, 20267.6 ±0.53–4↑2
- 65Harry Styles Madison Square Garden · Oct 30, 20267.6 ±0.54–3↑64
- 66Sam Gellaitry Coachella · Apr 13, 20247.5 ±0.53–5↓2
- 67Shygirl Pier 80 · Sep 29, 20247.5 ±0.54–3
- 68Lane 8 Golden Gate Park · Aug 8, 20267.5 ±0.54–4↓7
- 69it's murph Golden Gate Park · Aug 8, 20267.5 ±0.53–4
- 70John Summit Golden Gate Park · Aug 8, 20257.5 ±0.56–2
- 71Oskar Med K Pier 80 · Sep 26, 20267.5 ±0.54–3
- 72Jigitz Pier 80 · Sep 26, 20267.4 ±0.54–4↓7
- 73Swiming Paul Pier 80 · Sep 21, 20257.4 ±0.44–3↓1
- 74Gesaffelstein Golden Gate Park · Aug 9, 20257.4 ±0.45–5↓1
- 75Ben Sterling Pier 48 · Mar 13, 20267.4 ±0.55–3↑1
- 76Mau P Pier 80 · Sep 20, 20257.4 ±0.53–4↓1
- 77Veggi Regency · Mar 4, 20257.4 ±0.53–5↓3
- 78Romy Golden Gate Park · Aug 10, 20247.4 ±0.53–5↓10
- 79Disclosure Greek Theater · Sep 27, 20257.3 ±0.55–3↓2
- 80Layton Giordani Pier 80 Warehouse · Jan 1, 20267.3 ±0.39–9↓1
- 81Jamie xx + Floating Points + Daphni Coachella · Apr 14, 20247.3 ±0.64–3↓1
- 82MK Golden Gate Park · Aug 11, 20247.3 ±0.53–5↓1
- 83Chappell Roan Golden Gate Park · Aug 11, 20247.3 ±0.54–3↓1
- 84Armin van Buuren + Adam Beyer Coachella · Apr 18, 20267.3 ±0.63–4↑2
- 85Skrillex Pier 80 Warehouse · Dec 30, 20257.3 ±0.53–5↓2
- 86Maxi Meraki Coachella · Apr 19, 20267.3 ±0.53–4↑2
- 87Confidence Man Regency · Mar 4, 20257.3 ±0.54–4↓2
- 88Armin van Buuren + Adam Beyer Coachella · Apr 17, 20267.3 ±0.64–2↑5
- 89Kaskade Coachella · Apr 19, 20267.3 ±0.53–4↓11
- 90Japanese House Greek Theater · Oct 19, 20257.3 ±0.54–5↓6
- 91Kaskade Coachella · Apr 13, 20247.3 ±0.53–5↓4
- 92Tinashe Golden Gate Park · Aug 7, 20267.3 ±0.84–2↓3
- 93Kasablanca Golden Gate Park · Aug 9, 20247.2 ±0.54–4↓3
- 94Peggy Gou Coachella · Apr 12, 20247.2 ±0.65–2↓3
- 95Charli XCX Golden Gate Park · Aug 7, 20267.2 ±0.55–2
- 96Romy Golden Gate Park · Aug 7, 20267.2 ±0.53–4↓2
- 97Beltran + Ben Sterling Pier 80 Warehouse · Sep 26, 20267.2 ±0.52–5↓5
- 98Jamie xx Pier 80 · Sep 28, 20247.2 ±0.66–1↓1
- 99Devault Golden Gate Park · Aug 9, 20247.2 ±0.55–2↓3
- 100Sam Smith Chase Center · Aug 28, 20237.2 ±0.54–4↓2
- 101Anyma Coachella · Apr 14, 20247.1 ±0.54–3↓2
- 102Swedish House Mafia Pier 80 Warehouse · Dec 29, 20257.1 ±0.47–3↓2
- 103Walker & Royce Golden Gate Park · Aug 9, 20257.1 ±0.55–3↓1
- 104Green Velvet + AYYBO Coachella · Apr 19, 20267.1 ±0.54–3↑13
- 105Prospa + Kettama Pier 80 Warehouse · Sep 20, 20257.1 ±0.44–5↓1
- 106Max Styler Pier 80 Warehouse · Sep 26, 20267.1 ±0.52–5↓5
- 107Mochakk Coachella · Apr 19, 20267.0 ±0.54–3↑4
- 108Lil Nas X Zilker Park · Oct 8, 20227.0 ±0.53–5
- 109Slayyyter Coachella · Apr 17, 20267.0 ±0.53–4↓2
- 110Adéla Pier 80 · Sep 27, 20267.0 ±0.54–3↓5
- 111Michael Bibi Coachella · Apr 13, 20247.0 ±0.53–4↓5
- 112sombr Coachella · Apr 18, 20267.0 ±0.63–3↓2
- 113Carly Rae Jepsen Zilker Park · Oct 7, 20227.0 ±0.54–4↓10
- 114Kacey Musgraves Coachella · Apr 18, 20266.9 ±0.54–3↑4
- 115Duke Dumont Pier 80 Warehouse · Sep 20, 20256.9 ±0.55–3↓2
- 116Chris Lake Midway · Jan 1, 20256.9 ±0.54–6↓1
- 117Despacio Pier 80 · Sep 21, 20256.9 ±0.53–4↓3
- 118Mind Minds Golden Gate Park · Aug 13, 20236.9 ±0.53–4↓6
- 119Sultan + Shepard Golden Gate Park · Aug 8, 20266.9 ±0.62–5
- 120SG Lewis Pier 80 · Sep 27, 20266.9 ±0.54–4↓4
- 121Jessie Ware Pier 80 · Sep 28, 20246.9 ±0.55–3↓1
- 122Empire of the Sun Golden Gate Park · Aug 9, 20266.9 ±0.53–4
- 123GUDFELLA Coachella · Apr 18, 20266.8 ±0.53–4
- 124Japanese House Coachella · Apr 12, 20246.8 ±0.53–4
- 125Łaszewo Golden Gate Park · Aug 8, 20266.8 ±0.53–4↓4
- 126Nora En Pure Golden Gate Park · Aug 12, 20236.7 ±0.54–5
- 127Renee Rapp Coachella · Apr 14, 20246.7 ±0.54–5↓2
- 128Interplanetary Criminal Pier 80 Warehouse · Sep 28, 20246.7 ±0.55–3
- 129Armand Van Helden Pier 48 · Mar 7, 20266.7 ±0.64–1↓2
- 130Salute Public Works · Sep 19, 20256.7 ±0.45–6
- 131CIL Chase Center · Oct 12, 20256.6 ±0.63–6
- 132The Blessed Madonna + Tiga Pier 80 Warehouse · Sep 21, 20256.6 ±0.54–4
- 133CA7RIEL & Paco Amoroso The Masonic · Jul 11, 20266.6 ±0.54–2↑1
- 134Flume Zilker Park · Oct 8, 20226.5 ±0.53–4↓1
- 135Trixie Mattel Golden Gate Park · Aug 8, 20266.5 ±0.54–3↑12
- 136Tinashe Coachella · Apr 12, 20246.5 ±0.64–3↓1
- 137Royel Otis Coachella · Apr 18, 20266.5 ±0.54–3
- 138Confidence Man Pier 80 · Sep 20, 20256.5 ±0.45–8↓2
- 139Joy Orbison Pier 80 · Sep 28, 20246.5 ±0.54–3↓1
- 140Ben Böhmer Pier 80 · Sep 29, 20246.5 ±0.54–3↓1
- 141Prospa Pier 80 Warehouse · Sep 26, 20266.5 ±0.55–2↑11
- 142Haai Public Works · Sep 19, 20256.4 ±0.44–7↓2
- 143Kacey Musgraves Kia Forum · Oct 4, 20246.4 ±0.53–5↓2
- 144Sports Golden Gate Park · Aug 9, 20266.4 ±0.52–5↓2
- 145Zulan Coachella · Apr 18, 20266.4 ±0.54–3↓2
- 146Disco Lines Golden Gate Park · Aug 9, 20266.4 ±0.52–5↓2
- 147Effy + Mall Grab Pier 48 · May 16, 20266.4 ±0.53–4↑1
- 148JADE Golden Gate Park · Aug 9, 20266.3 ±0.53–3↓3
- 149Alison Wonderland Coachella · Apr 13, 20246.3 ±0.55–5↓3
- 150Bonobo Golden Gate Park · Aug 8, 20256.3 ±0.53–5↓1
- 151Magdalena Bay Pier 80 · Sep 20, 20256.3 ±0.55–4
- 152Alisha Coachella · Apr 17, 20266.3 ±0.52–5↑2
- 153Hozier Shoreline · Sep 10, 20246.3 ±0.43–9
- 154Fcukers Pier 80 · Sep 26, 20266.2 ±0.63–3↑1
- 155Mall Grab Coachella · Apr 14, 20246.2 ±0.62–5↑1
- 156X Club Golden Gate Park · Aug 9, 20266.2 ±0.55–2↑1
- 157Diplo Golden Gate Park · Sep 8, 20246.2 ±0.56–2↑1
- 158SZA Zilker Park · Oct 7, 20226.2 ±0.62–5↑1
- 159Duke Dumont Coachella · Apr 19, 20266.2 ±0.53–4↑1
- 160Kendrick Golden Gate Park · Aug 11, 20236.1 ±0.62–5↑1
- 161Zulan Pier 80 · Sep 27, 20266.1 ±0.54–4↓11
- 162CA7RIEL & Paco Amoroso Golden Gate Park · Aug 10, 20256.1 ±0.54–3
- 163X Club Pier 80 Warehouse · Sep 20, 20256.1 ±0.52–6
- 164Zedd Bill Graham · Oct 13, 20246.1 ±0.55–4
- 165Astra Club Pier 80 Warehouse · Sep 28, 20246.1 ±0.54–5
- 166Bonobo Bill Graham · Nov 15, 20256.0 ±0.53–6↑1
- 167Kaytranada Golden Gate Park · Aug 11, 20246.0 ±0.54–5↓1
- 168Zhu Bill Graham · Oct 20, 20236.0 ±0.54–4
- 169Bullet Tooth Greek Theater · Sep 27, 20256.0 ±0.53–4↑1
- 170Gryffin Golden Gate Park · Aug 9, 20246.0 ±0.54–4↓1
- 171Mindchatter Golden Gate Park · Aug 9, 20246.0 ±0.64–3
- 172Moby Coachella · Apr 17, 20265.9 ±0.64–2
- 173&friends Golden Gate Park · Aug 10, 20255.9 ±0.54–4
- 174Carlita Golden Gate Park · Aug 9, 20265.9 ±0.55–3↑1
- 175Sofia Kourtesis Golden Gate Park · Aug 10, 20245.9 ±0.53–4↓1
- 176Empress Of Greek Theater · Oct 19, 20255.9 ±0.54–6
- 177ILLENIUM Bill Graham · Nov 23, 20185.9 ±0.53–5↑1
- 178Diplo Zilker Park · Oct 8, 20225.9 ±0.62–5↓1
- 179yousuke yuk1matsu Pier 80 Warehouse · Sep 20, 20255.8 ±0.54–5
- 180Niminio Pier 80 · Sep 26, 20265.8 ±0.63–3
- 181Lavern Midway · Jul 6, 20245.8 ±0.62–5
- 182Zack Fox Pier 80 · Sep 20, 20255.8 ±0.54–5
- 183Despacio Pier 80 · Sep 27, 20265.7 ±0.62–4
- 184Marsh Golden Gate Park · Aug 9, 20245.7 ±0.53–5
- 185AlunaGeorge Regency · Jun 3, 20165.7 ±0.53–5
- 186Hugel Coachella · Apr 17, 20265.6 ±0.72–4
- 187Macklemore Bill Graham · May 28, 20165.6 ±0.64–3
- 188Dom Dolla + Disclosure Pier 48 · Oct 17, 20265.6 ±0.54–3
- 189Death Cab for Cutie Golden Gate Park · Aug 9, 20265.5 ±0.62–5
- 190DJ Seinfeld Pier 48 · Oct 17, 20265.5 ±0.53–3
- 191James Blake Zilker Park · Oct 7, 20225.4 ±0.54–3
- 192Sam Smith Warsaw NYC · Oct 30, 20255.4 ±0.54–5
- 193Glass Beams Shoreline · Aug 14, 20255.4 ±0.52–7
- 194Labrinth Golden Gate Park · Aug 7, 20265.4 ±0.62–4↑1
- 195Ludacris Golden Gate Park · Aug 9, 20255.3 ±0.53–5↓1
- 196Rebecca Black Golden Gate Park · Aug 10, 20255.3 ±0.54–3
- 197Doechii Bill Graham · Nov 7, 20255.3 ±0.53–5
- 198The Dare Pier 48 · May 16, 20265.3 ±0.61–7
- 199Peggy Gou Pier 48 · Mar 7, 20265.3 ±0.72–5
- 200Role Model Golden Gate Park · Aug 8, 20255.2 ±0.55–3
- 201Maribou State Pier 80 · Sep 21, 20255.2 ±0.52–7
- 202Haim Greek Theater · Oct 7, 20255.1 ±0.53–7
- 203Hamdi Coachella · Apr 18, 20264.9 ±0.62–4
- 204Natasha Bedingfield Pier 80 · Sep 28, 20244.9 ±0.53–7
- 205The Dare Bill Graham · May 21, 20254.9 ±0.62–5
- 206Rio Kosta Greek Theater · Oct 6, 20264.8 ±0.54–3
- 207Lana Del Rey Coachella · Apr 12, 20244.7 ±0.54–4
- 208Geese Golden Gate Park · Aug 7, 20264.6 ±0.62–5
- 209Dog Blood Pier 80 · Sep 26, 20264.5 ±0.61–4–1↑1
- 210Zhu Midway · Jan 1, 20254.5 ±0.53–6↑1
- 211Soulwax Pier 80 · Sep 28, 20244.4 ±0.52–7↓2
- 212Calvin Harris Pier 80 Warehouse · Feb 6, 20264.4 ±0.315–30
- 213Testpilot Bill Graham · Oct 20, 20234.2 ±0.62–6↑1
- 214Lana Del Rey Shoreline · May 20, 20154.2 ±0.61–6↓1
- 215Anyma Coachella · Apr 17, 20264.2 ±0.62–5↑1
- 216Ninajarachi Pier 80 · Sep 27, 20264.2 ±0.61–4–1↓1
- 217Arcade Fire Shoreline · Jul 30, 20143.9 ±0.52–8
- 218Father John Misty Kia Forum · Oct 4, 20243.7 ±0.61–8
- 219Blood Orange Pier 80 · Sep 21, 20253.6 ±0.71–7
- 220Shaboozey Golden Gate Park · Aug 9, 20243.2 ±0.80–8
- 221Diplo Pier 80 Warehouse · Feb 6, 20263.0 ±0.61–5
Gut vs Power
Patterns
How often, how highly, and when: shows per year, the spread of ratings, and a month-by-month calendar.
By Year
By Year
Distribution
Distribution
Concert Calendar
Chronological ledger
reviewhideof Diplo & Calvin Harris
crowd/vibes: far too many 21 year olds, no one was really locked in, lots of chit chatting (understandable because it was kinda boring). Lots of non-SF people... I was worried that all of this would be the case for the NYE warehouse shows but all those crowds were 10/10! but also football is the polar opposite from my culture
mixing: diplo was really bad, most of the transitions were super rough (this is where i would say, i think i could dj better LOL). calvin was fine at best. really surprising since they've been doing this for decades
track selection & flow: diplo played some remixes of songs that were worse than the original versions of the songs i thought. in general was alllll over the place with genres, the next song felt completely random (derogatory). same with calvin harris, like you can't play a 2016 radio hit and then switch into techno for 3 minutes out of the blue without easing the crowd in! i got no story/vision/journey, it was giving shuffle. it did feel like they were catering to the crowd but you can still read the room and do a job at it...
production: also too much in a bad way, too bright and too many lasers for too long that like it felt in my mind what a vegas club is like, the lighting also felt like it didn't contribute to the flow or add any tension, and it was maxxed out most of the time instead of being saved to use intentionally
overall: diplo Rating 2/10, calvin harris Rating 3/10
compare this to like, in recent memory for me, fred again Rating 10/10 or four tet Rating 9/10 where everything feels so much more cohesive and intentional, they can play the most left field song next but it somehow works, there's an overarching story that ebbs and flows in a good way, and the lighting adds to that